Food review: Lady Mildmay, Newington Green

PUBLISHED: 16:32 16 September 2016 | UPDATED: 17:04 16 September 2016

Lady Mildmay in Newington Green. Picture: Steve Hall

Lady Mildmay in Newington Green. Picture: Steve Hall


Newington Green is home to The Alma, one of my all time favourite pubs. But tonight I am visiting the Lady Mildmay, just around the corner. Bearing in mind the location, it has a lot to live up to.

Starters at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng Starters at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng

It is warm, dimly lit and Saturday night chatter bounces off the echoey ceiling. In other words it’s a perfect drinking pub.

With a Hammerton N7 pale ale (brewed in Islington) for myself and fine Spanish white wine for my friend, we scour the menu written in chalk on the wall.

Refurbing and reopening earlier this year, landlord Steve Hall is clearly striving for more. In terms of pub fare, it’s the bravest I’ve seen. Not a chip, burger or pie in sight. Instead, Mediterranean-inspired dishes full of flavour.

To start, I devour lamb meatballs in tomato sauce and yoghurt (£6.50). Though the four meatballs are small, the richness of this fresh-tasting sauce means the portion is a perfect size.

Main at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng Main at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng

My friend, meanwhile, goes for sardines with pomegranate and tapenade (£6.50). As someone whose weakness is seafood, she can’t believe her luck at this dish: “Enough to be a main,” she reports. “Fragrantly charred to perfection.”

I choose blade steak in a borlotti bean stew with chimmi churro (£15.50) for my main. The delicate meat is juicy, with more of the charring experienced by my friend in her starter. It’s the type of dish you deliberately take your time to savour.

My friend is slightly less enamoured with her Portugese pork and clam stew (£13.50). As ever, she enjoys the seafood element. But the sauce is slightly over-salted, upsetting the balance of flavours.

Our friendly waiter recommends the chocolate mousse, which I am delighted to go along with. While my less greedy friend enjoys ice cream, I am stunned at the pure intensity of the chocolate flavour. It’s my favourite dish of the night.

Dessert at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng Dessert at the Lady Mildmay. Picture: Carline Cheng

So it’s clear the Lady Mildmay has a good thing going on. Even if you’re not enthused by the sophisticated (and admittedly fairly pricy) menu, this pub remains an excellent drinking establishment. And if you want to try out a different kind of pub food, this is your place.

Lady Mildmay: 92, Mildmay Park, N1 4PR. Visit or call 020 7241 6238.

Latest Islington Entertainment Stories

Thursday, June 14, 2018

The World Cup kicks off tonight. That means two things: a month of seriously dull football matches which remind you why international football isn’t very good, and restaurateurs flogging World Cup-themed burgers.

Wednesday, June 13, 2018

A topical revival of unsung expressionist play inspired by the real life case of Ruth Snyder who killed her abusive husband

Monday, June 11, 2018

A tender and intimate revival of Brian Friel’s epic tale of love and language in rural 1830s Ireland

Sunday, June 10, 2018

Farang has put Thai food on the map in Highbury Park in a former Italian trattoria. Emma Bartholomew visits with her family


Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read entertainment

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now