Court refuses Islington council’s appeal against leaseholder tribunal ruling

15:40 18 August 2012

Islington Council may still take the case to a higher court

Islington Council may still take the case to a higher court


Days before a TV expose about leaseholders rip offs featuring Islington Council, one group of resident’s hope their battle is at an end after Town Hall wasn’t allowed to appeal a ruling it blew £1million overpaying on housing improvements.

Monday’s edition of investigative Channel Four show Dispatches features the Tremlett Grove Estate, in Archway, which in April the Leasholder Valuation Tribunal (LVT) judged the council paid over the odds to the tune of seven figures for work on two blocks.

The ruling meant the council will have to cut £225,000 of the charge to the 14 leaseholders affected – around £16,000 each.

Later that month the council appealed the decision, but the LVT refused them the right to appeal.

The council then took the appeal to the Lands Tribunal, a higher body than the LVT, who also refused the right of appeal on August 2.

Judy Granville, 62, one of the leaseholders who launched the original action, said: “This is a huge vindication for me. There has been so many ups and downs, with the council appealing on two occasions, that I will wait before popping any corks.

“The fact that the council were told to get on their bike by the Lands Tribunal is excellent news.”

However the council are still refusing to give up and can now take the appeal to the Administrative Court, a division of the High Court, on a point of law.

A spokesman for the council said: “The flat roofs at Tremlett Grove and Merryweather Court are more than 40 years old, and Government guidance is that after 30 years roofs in poor condition should be replaced, not repaired.

“The tribunal is not saying that this work was unnecessary, but rather they wanted more evidence to prove it was necessary.

“That is why we are considering an appeal against the tribunal’s finding.

“Islington will continue to make investment decisions based on the long-term interests of the residents and stock.”

Latest News Stories

Sarah Dunant (L), artist and refugee Neda with her artwork, and actress Juliet Stevenson (R)

The Islington Centre for Refugees and Migrants is urgently appealing for more donations in the run-up to Christmas in order to stay open for an extra day each week.

Ligia Stan and Petre Craciun with the Hummingbird

With rising transport costs, increasing numbers of people are choosing to cycle to work these days. But many are still put off by the risk of having their bike stolen, as well as the thought of lugging it on public transport for part of the journey.

The man police want to identify for attempted arson at Finsbury Park Mosque

This is the man police want to identify after an attempted arson at Finsbury Park Mosque on Friday.

Cllr Richard Watts

The leader of Islington Council wants “lively discussion” at a Question Time-style public meeting tomorrow.

Yesterday, 13:57
Police want to talk to this man over an attempted arson at Finsbury Park Mosque

Police are hunting a moped rider suspected of trying to set Finsbury Park Mosque on fire in what is being treated as a “hate crime”.

Saturday, November 28, 2015
Fergus conducting the English National Opera. Picture: Tom Bowles/English National Opera

Anyone can enjoy opera. Shrewsbury Town FC is proof of that.

Friday, November 27, 2015
Year 6 pupils interview the school's Site Manager, Robbie Robinson, about his memories of the Apollo missions

Pupils at Vittoria Primary School, Islington, are keen to talk to people who remember the Apollo space missions and Neil Armstrong’s first steps on the moon for a history project.

Friday, November 27, 2015
Prince Philip presents Dr Alasdair Harris with the Duke of Edinburgh Conservation Award

The founder of an Islington-based charity was this week presented with the 2015 Duke of Edinburgh Conservation Award for contributions to marine conservation.

Most read news


Nike Trainers

Nike’s motto is ‘to bring inspiration and innovation to every athlete in the world.’ With this in mind it’s no surprise why Nike is the preferred training gear for most A-list athletes. Get an extra boost in your run or height in your jump with £500 to spend on Nike trainers.

MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!

Digital Edition

Read the Islington Gazette e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder