Crisis team refused to assess Highbury woman days before suicide

07:03 09 July 2012




A suicidal mother was denied a full assessment by a mental health crisis team days before she killed herself, an inquest heard.

Francine Vladermersky, 52, was refused a face-to-face assessment by the North Islington Crisis Resolution Team after being screened over the phone by a nurse – even though one is offered in nearly every case.

This was despite being referred to the team by an experienced GP who was deeply concerned about her talk of wanting “to go to sleep and not have to face the world”, St Pancras Coroners’ Court was told.

Her brother found her drowned in the bath of her home in Ashburton Triangle, Highbury, three days later, on Sunday April 1.

Coroner Dr Shirley Radcliffe said: “I feel that if an experienced GP has made the referral, that should warrant at least a face-to-face assessment with a mental health worker.

“I can’t possibly say it would have made a difference if anything was done differently. But I feel strongly everyone referred to this centre should have a face-to-face assessment, it’s the very least that families can expect.”

The court heard Ms Vladermersky had a long history of anxiety and depression, linked to her troubled relationship with her son. Her ex-partner Christian Forster, the father, said: “He had been attacking her. It started about three years ago. Social services were saying if it happened again, he could kill her. She was physically frightened of him.”

The coroner gave the cause of death as drowning due to alcohol intoxication and recorded a verdict of suicide.

Dr Radcliffe stopped short of directly criticising the decisions of the medical professionals involved. A spokesman for the Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust, which runs the crisis team, said: “The trust would like to offer its sincere condolences to the family of Francine Vladermersky.

“Decisions about assessments are made on a case by case basis by our clinicians and neither the GP nor the coroner criticised the trust’s decision about the assessment in this case.”

The nurse who screened Ms Vladermersky, Aisling Clifford, said the crisis team was planning to offer all GP referrals a full assessment in future, although the trust would not confirm this.

Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 15:54
London Metropolitan University's campus in Holloway. The university has announced plans to move all of its faculties onto one new campus, for the first time in its 170-year history. Picture: London Metropolitan University

An ambitious £125million scheme to transform a university site into a “showpiece” campus has been announced.

Yesterday, 12:51
Holloway Road, Holloway, where a suspected mugger fell ill after being detained by members of the public and handcuffed by police. He died in hospital on Saturday. Picture: Google Street View.

A post-mortem examination on a suspected mugger who died after being detained by members of the public was inconclusive, police have revealed.

Yesterday, 11:00
An artist's impression of how Barnard Park would look after redevelopment, including the new football pitch and green spaces

Islington’s footballers stand to benefit from plans to overhaul one of the borough’s main parks.

Yesterday, 10:51
Former Holloway Prison guard Joseph de Souza, 51, has been sentenced to 12 weeks in jail after pleading guilty to one count of committing misconduct in a public office. Picture: PA

A former prison officer who sold tips to the Daily Mirror about the mother of tragic Baby P has been jailed for 12 weeks.

Yesterday, 07:00
Cllr Watts cuts the ribbon with Frances Punter and Tracey Breslin of the tenants and residents group

A disused storeroom has been converted into the heartbeat of a community.

Saturday, October 10, 2015
Emma with Edie and Arthur

A mum is braving the fifth anniversary of her baby being stillborn by running the Royal Parks Foundation Half Marathon tomorrow.

Friday, October 9, 2015
Volunteers will help sufferers of dementia to continue doing their favourite hobbies

A local Alzheimer’s charity is looking for volunteers for a new service to help people with dementia.

Friday, October 9, 2015
The man whose body was recovered from the Regent’s Canal has been named as Sebastiano Magnanini

Paul Williams, 61, of no fixed abode was on the evening of Thursday, October 8, charged with preventing lawful burial.

Most read news


Angharad Baa Stool in Rare Breed.

Great British Life is offering a sheepskin footstool worth £199 to a lucky reader

Amazon: Everything you want to buy all in one place!

With £1,500 to spend online at Amazon, there’s really nothing you can’t buy.

You'll be stocked up on toiletries  for a while!

Cosmetics, toiletries, vitamins and more.

Digital Edition

Read the Islington Gazette e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder