Islington dog mess fines plummet despite £240,000 “dog squad”

12:03 14 August 2013

Cllr Paul Smith launched the dog squad last year

Cllr Paul Smith launched the dog squad last year


Town hall chiefs stand accused of making a mess of dog-fouling laws while fines for offenders continue to fall – despite splashing £240,000 on Britain’s biggest “dog squad”.

Figures obtained by the Gazette show Islington Council issued just 36 fines for dog fouling last year, down 35 per cent from three years ago despite last year launching the costly 22-man pooch police unit to catch owners.

In March last year, when the dog detectives were announced, the man behind the scheme – former executive member for environment Paul Smith – said: “If you don’t clean up after your dog, with 22 officers patrolling all hours of the day, you will get caught and you will be fined.”

But this week he denied the policy had been a flop and defended it despite the failure to catch more offenders – claiming it was “money well spent”.

With the maximum fine being £80, the most Islington will have made from fines last year is £2,880.

Henry Zarb, the Taxpayers’ Alliance coordinator for Islington, branded the project a staggering waste of money.

He said: “It’s absolutely shocking that they would perform less well having spent vastly more money. It seems extraordinary and a staggeringly inefficient way of getting things done.

“Somebody at the council isn’t doing their cost benefit analysis before they start projects like this.

“It seems like a complete waste of money and it hasn’t helped the situation. I find, as I’m sure a lot of other residents do, that dog mess still seems to often be everywhere.”

The figures show the total number of fixed penalty notices issued by Islington Council was 55 in 2010/11, 46 for 2011/12 and 36 for 2012/13 – the year the dog squad was launched in May for just 12 weeks before being discontinued.

Fines are lowered to £50 if owners pay within 10 days. Many London boroughs threaten fines of up to £1,000.

Cllr Smith said: “The dog squad was an enormous success in changing people’s behaviour. It was money well spent and we were pleased with the result.

“If people stop doing the wrong thing that’s a success. The aim isn’t necessarily to get money, it’s to have less people doing the wrong thing.”

Cllr Rakhia Ismail, executive member for sustainability, who took over from Cllr Smith after he lost his place on the executive, said: “Fixed penalty notices are just one part of what we do.

“We also focus resources into education and face-to-face encouragement with dog owners which we believe is helping to tackle and change bad behaviour.”

The top five poo hot spots are said to be Halliford Street, Thornhill Crescent, and Arundel Square in Islington, Hornsey Rise Gardens in Hornsey Rise and Roman Way in Holloway.


Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 15:52
Ashley Walters at the launch of the Radio 1 and 1Xtra Academy at Stoke Newington School in 2012. Picture: Carmen Valino

Rapper and actor Ashley Walters will appear at crown court over two accusations of threatening behaviour and one of racially aggravated harassment in Upper Street’s Hilton Hotel on May 3.

Yesterday, 12:49
Cllr Richard Watts

More than 1,000 of Islington’s unemployed have found jobs in the last year, thanks to a council-led scheme.

Yesterday, 10:48
Mélanie Lambert works at Le Sacré Coeur restaurant in Islington

A French waitress working in Islington says she is trying to stay strong after two of her friends were killed in the Paris terror attacks.

Yesterday, 09:00
The attack occured on the junction of Northdown Street and Pentonville Road. Picture: Google Street View

Crimestoppers and BT Openreach have launched an appeal for information after damage to a telecommunications network in King’s Cross left nearby businesses and homes without telephone and broadband services.

Yesterday, 07:00
Mayor of London Boris Johnson discusses knife crime with Brooke and Deborah Kinsella on Tuesday

Before 2015 is out, knife crime in Islington is already at its highest rate since 2010.

Wed, 16:00
Members of the Ben Kinsella Trust meeting with Boris Johnson at the Finsbury Library to discuss knife crime in London

Mayor of London Boris Johnson has urged more stop and searches to tackle Islington’s knife shame.

Wed, 14:29
Islington is lit up at Angel Central's festive extravaganza last weekend

Christmas lights switch-on events will bring festive cheer across Islington this month – with each one offering something slightly different.

Most read news


MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!


You are never far from an Argos, wherever in the country you may be. They are like a magical cavern where whatever you need they seem to have it out the back behind the counter. So why not put them to the test with this great MyOffers competition to win £1000 to spend in-store.

Digital Edition

Read the Islington Gazette e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder