Islington and City Hall housing chiefs call on surveyors to stop developers skimping on affordable homes

PUBLISHED: 13:49 09 October 2018

Islington Council leader Richard Watts, centre, meets staff at the Dover Court site where new council homes were being built. Picture: Steve Bainbridge

Islington Council leader Richard Watts, centre, meets staff at the Dover Court site where new council homes were being built. Picture: Steve Bainbridge

Steve Bainbridge Photography Ltd

Islington’s housing chief and his City Hall equivalent are lobbying surveyors to stop developers wriggling out of their duty to build affordable homes.

Cllr Diarmaid Ward and Sadiq Khan’s deputy mayor James Murray – who used to have Cllr Ward’s job at Islington – have written an open letter to the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) asking bosses to update their official guidance.

It references Islington’s “game-changing” High Court victory this year regarding financial viability assessments.

Viability assessments determine the cost of a potential project for developers, who often use them to argue they cannot meet a council’s required number of affordable homes. In Islington, that’s half of any major project.

They will often say they have overpaid for the land – coughing up what it could potentially be worth if they get pie-in-the-sky planning permission to build huge numbers of private flats – and therefore can’t afford to build the social homes Islington needs.

Islington changed its own guidance surrounding viability and the valuing of land in 2016 to stop this happening by refusing to recognise anything but the genuine value of a site when making concessions about cheaper homes.

But by the time a project gets to the council’s planning committee it is effectively too late, because the land has already been bought based on what surveyors – who use RICS’ national guidance for valuing – recommend.

Islington can still reject an application for not following its guidance, but then a lengthy appeal process usually ensues that slows down the arrival of the new homes and could see their decision overturned by the Planning Inspectorate anyway.

Now, though, the council is armed with the High Court ruling regarding a former Territorial Army site in Parkhurst Road in which judge David Holgate made the highly unusual move of recommending RICS revisits its own guidance.

Cllr Ward said: “There is a shortage of good quality, genuinely affordable housing in London and Islington is feeling this deeply.

“The council is doing everything it can to help tackle the problem – we have built more new council homes in the last four years than we have in the previous 30.

“But there are still too many families desperately in need of secure, genuinely affordable homes and developers need to do their part.

“Developers should respect local planning requirements and take this into account when purchasing new sites, rather than overpaying for land and then trying to bypass affordable housing requirements.”

Mr Murray added: “The mayor wants to see more social rented and other genuinely affordable homes built in London – so alongside councils building more homes themselves, that means developers doing their bit too. We need clear planning guidance without any loopholes.”

Related articles

Latest Islington News Stories

Yesterday, 14:23

Neighbours described the “heartbreaking” moment an 18-year-old was stabbed in Canonbury last night – his attacker is still at large.

Yesterday, 10:12

Wireless promoter Live Nation has been given the green light to carry on holding the festival in Finsbury Park after a licensing review – but artists will be “encouraged” not to swear.

Yesterday, 09:04

The victims commissioner is visiting the Ben Kinsella Trust today to learn about its life-saving workshops, which educate young people about the horror of carrying knives.

Yesterday, 08:54

Year 5 kids from St John the Evangelist school have designed a “vibrant” and “energetic” tapestry for The Charterhouse.

Mon, 13:00

An innovative NHS project that hires people with first-hand experience of mental illness to support mental health patients across Islington has won a national award.

Mon, 11:59

A hundred neighbours were rushed from their beds on Saturday evening as a major gas leak saw Green Lanes locked down.

Mon, 10:48

A chatty Big Issue seller who died alone in a hostel room. A table tennis-playing “teddy bear” who killed himself. At least four people who were homeless in Islington have died over the last 12 months, but no one is recording their deaths.

Mon, 07:55

Islington has enrolled in national anti-sugar campaign to battle tooth decay and unhealthy diets.


Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now