Islington Council loses fight against office to flat conversions

PUBLISHED: 10:03 24 December 2013 | UPDATED: 10:03 24 December 2013

Cllr James Murray, Islington Council's executive member for housing

Cllr James Murray, Islington Council's executive member for housing


Protection of business space in the borough is out of town hall hands after a legal challenge against the government failed.

Islington Council lead the fight against the General Permitted Development Order – the decision to relax planning laws in May which 
allows office space to be changed to residential without council approval.

The legal challenge, supported by Camden and Richmond upon Thames councils, centred around the way the government handled the process for seeking exemptions from the new permitted development rights, which the boroughs argued was unfair.

As well as losing jobs, the council is concerned the new rules will prevent them from controlling the type of housing offices are changed to, denting its target of 50 per cent of all new homes being affordable.


The only area exempt from the ruling is the Central Activities Zone which covers parts of Finsbury, Clerkenwell and St Luke’s.

Islington has already received 58 notifications of offices being changed to residential use, and plans to turn the council’s offices at Highbury House into 35 flats were submitted earlier this month.

Cllr James Murray, Islington Council’s executive member for housing and development, said: “This government policy has created a reckless free-for-all in the planning system. We are very concerned about its impact and so we are disappointed by the outcome of this case.

“The loss of all these offices is damaging our local economy and it’s not producing the sort of homes we need.

“There is no control over the quality or size of the new flats, and they don’t include any affordable housing at all – a fact the judge felt was worrying and that we know is very bad news for Islington.”

The legal challenge was heard at High Court on December 4 and the decision was made on Friday.

Mr Justice Collins, who gave the verdict, said the he understood the concerns which led to the claims by the boroughs, and added that “the lack of any requirement for affordable housing is worrying”.

However, his overall conclusion was that the government’s actions were not unlawful.


Latest Islington News Stories

Lee Jay Hatley’s alleged murderer accidentally knifed him in a “scuffle”, a court heard today.


Two moped thugs from Islington have been locked up for more than three years after being chased and caught with 17 stolen phones.

Two homeless women who had been sleeping under the Stroud Green Road bridge for a year have been offered housing – weeks after the Gazette published the tragic stories of how they had ended up there.


Islington is notorious for brutally high rent. But a brilliant yoga centre for people with special needs has been given a brand new premises for just £1,000 a year.

Migrants who arrive in Islington face a daunting prospect: mountains of government paperwork in a language they often aren’t familiar with; a ban on getting certain state benefits; and no legal help.


Dozens of new council homes were unveiled on Finsbury’s King Square Estate yesterday as part of a major regeneration.

Yesterday, 19:01

It was a lesson in politics for a set of inquisitive youngsters during a visit to the council chamber at Islington Town Hall.

Yesterday, 15:42

Today, it’s the pricey trampoline park that has the Sobell in the headlines. Four (and a bit) decades ago, it opened amid similar protests about how much it would cost. In between, it played a crucial role in Britain’s decision to join and then leave the EEC and the EU. The Gazette chats to 1970s Sobell manager Hywel Griffiths.

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now