Readers' Letters

Readers' Letters

Editor’s comment: Can we have our affordable homes now?

PUBLISHED: 15:00 02 May 2018

The Territorial Army site in Parkhurst Road has been the subject of a five-year planning battle. Picture: GOOGLE STREET VIEW

The Territorial Army site in Parkhurst Road has been the subject of a five-year planning battle. Picture: GOOGLE STREET VIEW


The delapidated old Territorial Army base in Holloway doesn’t look like much.

Not unless you’re the rather specifically named Parkhurst Road Ltd, anyway, in which case it looks like something that is worth paying through the nose for and then spending goodness knows how much money and five years bickering over.

What I find galling isn’t just that PRL tried to weasel out of providing enough affordable housing in a borough that has a waiting list of 18,300 households.

It’s also that this refusal to build affordable housing became seemingly a matter of principle, to the extent PRL was willing to plough five or six figures of legal fees (its own, the council’s and the government’s) into fighting its requirement to do what is manifestly the right thing – that it was happy to pay for a five-year legal wrangle, but not to pay for any affordable homes.

Without going too far into the business of viability assessments, because I am not a planning expert, the developers’ case was broadly that they shouldn’t be expected to provide the 50 per cent affordable homes Islington requires as a starting point – because they’d overpaid for the site in what they themselves described as a “competitive bidding process” in 2013. There was a huge discrepancy between what Islington Council thought the land was worth (£6.75m) and what PRL thought (£11.9m, based on a controversial valuation procedure called benchmarking).

So what happens now? Hopefully, anyone considering taking the land off PRL’s tired hands will bear in mind the likely requirement to, y’know, put affordable homes on it – meaning they’ll only pay what the land is worth, which won’t be enough for PRL to recoup its costs. So is it too much to hope PRL might instead hang onto it and actually go ahead and build something?

Related articles

Latest Islington Stories

3 minutes ago

Bernd Leno has been speaking to the Islington Gazette after making his debut in the Europa League against Vorskla Poltava at the Emirates on Thursday evening.


Finsbury Park will bid to continue their perfect start to the new Herts/Middlesex One season when they travel away to play UCS Old Boys on Saturday.


An architect has slammed “petty” Islington planners who have again told him to demolish his multi-award winning block in Clerkenwell.


Sheltered housing tenants in Islington fear planned cutbacks to the service could see people left to die in their flats.


Two people were injured after a gunman opened fire in Essex Road last night.

Yesterday, 23:26

Arsenal boss Unai Emery has been left frustrated after the Gunners conceded two late goals in his sides 4-2 victory over FC Vorskla Poltava.

Yesterday, 21:58

Arsenal began their Europa League journey with a dominant 4-2 win over FC Vorskla Poltava on Thursday night.

Yesterday, 21:53

Arsenal hosted Vorskla Poltava in their opening match in Group E of the Europa League at the Emirates on Thursday evening. Read on for Layth Yousif’s PLAYER RATINGS


Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now