Search

Readers' Letters

Readers' Letters

Editor’s comment: Developers shouldn’t be calling shots

PUBLISHED: 14:06 11 October 2017 | UPDATED: 17:31 12 October 2017

Protest banners hung from Bernard Morgan House, facing the development site. Picture: EMMA MATTHEWS

Protest banners hung from Bernard Morgan House, facing the development site. Picture: EMMA MATTHEWS

Archant

When it applied for permission to demolish the old Bernard Morgan House and build 104 luxury flats with a private cinema on the Golden Lane Estate, Taylor Wimpey argued that it couldn’t afford more than a £1.5million contribution towards “affordable” housing.

That’s the equivalent of nine social flats – less than a tenth of the development.

Then it turned out Taylor Wimpey had not only underestimated what the flats would be worth, but also overestimated how much the land would cost. The City of London Corporation told it to come back with £4.5m – the equivalent of 27pc – which was somehow found after all.

For cash contributions that will go towards off-site affordable housing, the City’s own planning policy says this figure should be closer to 60pc.

So why did planners sign off a development with less than half that?

Because, basically, councils prioritise the desperate need for genuinely affordable housing below the expectation that developers should always expect to make a hefty profit. The tail is wagging the dog.

The questionable logic is that if these companies only expect to walk away with, say, 5pc profit – still an eye-watering amount – they simply won’t bother building anything at all.

One wonders what might have happened had the cross-boundary plan for the Golden Lane Estate put the luxury block on our side of the fence: Islington recently reaffirmed its commitment to getting 50pc affordable housing out of every development it signs off.

As I said in this space back in July, if London worked together to insist on that figure across borough boundaries, it could be a powerful tool in tackling the housing crisis.

But as it is, developers need only go a few yards down the road for a better deal.

Related articles

Latest Islington Stories

A pedestrian is in hospital after getting hit by a bus in City Road today.

Haringey is “prostituting” Finsbury Park out for Wireless Festival and should scrap the event, neighbours argued at a licensing sub-committee meeting last night.

09:05

The National Basketball Association (NBA) and Sky Sports today announced a new four-year broadcast and multiplatform partnership that will see Sky Sports become the NBA’s exclusive broadcast partner and official website operator in the UK and Ireland.

Yesterday, 18:00

The National Basketball Association (NBA) and Norwegian announced today a partnership that sees the award-winning airline named presenting partner of the NBA London Game 2019.

Yesterday, 16:23

Up to 100 children looted cheap sweets from a supermarket off Stroud Green Road and threw missiles at cars in the early hours of Sunday morning.

Yesterday, 14:52

Islington’s transport chief fears ticket office closures at two Overground stations in the borough will hit vulnerable people hardest.

Yesterday, 14:51

A new “eco-mooring zone” will be created for visiting boats between York Way and Danbury Street on the Regent’s Canal.

Yesterday, 12:24

Islington Council has withdrawn its representation ahead of today’s Wireless Festival licensing hearing, saying promoters have agreed to their demands.

PROMOTED CONTENT

Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now