Readers' Letters

Readers' Letters

Editor’s comment: Isha’s plans will break up a community

PUBLISHED: 15:01 06 June 2018 | UPDATED: 18:29 07 June 2018

Residents of St Mary's Path Estate. Picture: POLLY HANCOCK

Residents of St Mary's Path Estate. Picture: POLLY HANCOCK

Polly Hancock

Talk about a Pyrrhic victory.

Protect Our Estate Together (Poet) has fought an admirable battle against Islington and Shoreditch Housing Association (Isha) to save the St Mary’s Path Estate from demolition.

Isha, which hasn’t responded to a single request for comment from the Gazette in the eight months since we broke the story, has responded by taking demolition off the table – but finding a way to break up the community regardless.

Half the homes on the estate are three- or four-bed. And all of those are now set to be be replaced by one- and two-bed flats, leaving dozens of families with nowhere to go.

We can only guess at Isha’s intentions, but it’s a bit reminiscent of making all the unionists at a company redundant so the remaining workforce is too weak to fight for its rights. Poet has proven itself quite the thorn in Isha’s side, thanks in no small part to the support of St Mary’s Church, and may well have held things up with its pesky independent damp survey and articulate questioning at public meetings.

There’s some fairly sinister detail buried in the generously named “customer conversation” document distributed last month. For instance: “If a customer rejects an offer of suitable alternative accommodation ISHA will institute court proceedings to obtain possession.” There’s nothing about where these homes might end up being, or who gets to decide what accommodation is deemed “suitable”. Details, again, that Isha might be able to clarify were it to return our calls.

Curiously, it’s also included a box for “general comments” and space to “tell us what is important to you”. I think the community has already made its views pretty clear, and so has Isha – so why it thinks anyone would bother is something of a mystery.

Latest Islington Stories


As Americans everywhere prepare for a turkey feast with extra helpings of pumpkin pie, we’ve been out finding five of the best places for Thanksgiving this side of the Atlantic.

A witness broke down in tears as she spoke of the real life “horror movie” that was Marcel Campbell’s fatal stabbing in Upper Street.

Yesterday, 16:02

Burhan Sonmez had survived an attempted murder by police in Turkey before he was exiled in Britain and supported by an Islington charity.

Yesterday, 11:49

Sandy Marks’ future membership of the Labour Party is uncertain even after a QC-led review confirmed the Gazette’s revelations about the ex-mayor’s pro-paedophile past.

Yesterday, 11:44

An organisation acting for victims and survivors of abuse in Islington children’s homes has responded bitterly to a barrister’s conclusion that there was no evidence “organised” wrongdoing had taken place.

Yesterday, 11:04

The Charterhouse is offering “a treasure trove” of seasonal treats at its first ever Christmas fair in Clerkenwell today.

Yesterday, 10:00

The latest boxing news from Islington

Mon, 15:37

The head chef at a Holloway care home is in the final of a national cooking competition.


Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now