Emily Thornberry brands Pentonville “a disgrace to civilised society” and says it should be bulldozed

PUBLISHED: 17:08 23 August 2018 | UPDATED: 17:09 23 August 2018

Pentonville Prison in Caledonian Road. Picture: Charlotte Ball/PA Archive

Pentonville Prison in Caledonian Road. Picture: Charlotte Ball/PA Archive

PA Archive/PA Images

Emily Thornberry today said Islington’s HMP Pentonville is “a disgrace to civilised society” that should be bulldozed and replaced with smaller, modern prisons in central London.

Pentonville Prison. Picture: Charlotte Ball/PA WirePentonville Prison. Picture: Charlotte Ball/PA Wire

Ms Thornberry has repeatedly called for the overcrowded, under-staffed and dilapidated Victorian jail to be closed and expressed her concern that inmates and staff continue to be put at risk.

Her latest plea comes a day after the independent monitoring board (IMB), a prison watchdog, delivered yet another damning report on the “inhumane” conditions at the secure facility, in Caledonian Road. The board publishes similarly critical reports every year, warning in 2016 that inmates were regularly being flown drugs by drone that they were taking inside the prison walls before collapsing.

The shadow foreign secretary told the Gazette: “Pentonville is miserable, unsafe and inhumane and I’m afraid this report shows it’s got even worse.

“It’s even more overcrowded now than it was during the Victorian era and the conditions are a disgrace to civilised society.”

Islington South and Finsbury MP Emily Thornberry: 'Gangs have been controlling the Pentonville Prison walls for more than a year.' Pictures: PAIslington South and Finsbury MP Emily Thornberry: 'Gangs have been controlling the Pentonville Prison walls for more than a year.' Pictures: PA

The IMB report highlights, for the third year in a row, that Pentonville has contraband-porous windows that urgently need to be replaced.

Ms Thornberry said: “Local residents residents always contact me about the gangs hanging around outside the prison who are getting the drugs through the windows.”

This system also leads to weapons entering the prison, the devastating consequences of which were highlighted when inmate Jamal Mahmoud was stabbed to death in October 2016. The IMB report also notes a rise in Pentonville’s violent incidents this year, with 17 members of staff assaulted in March alone and an “increase in gang-related incidents during gatherings for prayer”.

“Pentonville should absolutely be closed,” said Ms Thornberry. “And replaced with smaller modern prisons in central London, rather than the middle of nowhere, so family can visit.”

She conceded parts of the prison are listed, such as the original gallows below, but said: “Hard decisions need to be made: either invest in improving the prison or the government needs to close it down.”

Ms Thornberry said the Ministry of Justice (MOJ), and the Home Office before it, have both made the mistake of not investing in Pentonville because they think they might knock it down one day but then “never get around to it”.

When asked what else the land could be used for, Ms Thornberry said: “If additional space became available in Islington people will want more affordable housing built.”

The IMB report also there noted there is a rodent infestation, and said: “Persistent overcrowding and the crumbling physical condition are incompatible with maintaining prisoners’ humanity and dignity.”

An MOJ spokesperson said: “We are investing £16m across the estate to bring prisons back up to acceptable standards, and work is underway to fix Pentonville’s old windows and grilles with around 30 per cent already replaced.

“The prison is seeing a reduction in drug use thanks to new netting, as well as regular sniffer dog and staff-led searches. In addition, 35 new prison officers have been recruited and we are working with charities to better identify and rehabilitate known gang members at Pentonville.”

They added: “The problems in our prisons will not be fixed overnight. But reducing crowding is a central aim of our modernisation plans - precisely why we have committed to delivering up to 10,000 new prison places across the country.”

Latest Islington News Stories

Islington Council has set its sights on Clerkenwell Fire Station, Sainsbury’s in Liverpool Road and the Seven Sisters Road gyratory in a major planning document covering the next 17 years.

Islington’s housing boss blasted the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) for using the former HM Holloway Prison as a “cash cow” last night – and the community again demanded the site be reopened and converted into council homes.

Jeremy Corbyn has promised to “end the rip off” that saw Islington Council splash out £42,574,508 for two Public Finance Initiative (PFI) deals in the past financial year.


Two-long standing stallholders have been named Islington’s Market Traders of the Year after the judges couldn’t split them.

Yesterday, 15:42

Police want to speak to this woman over £1,500 worth of damage to a minicab caused by two passengers.

Finsbury Park has been stripped of its Green Flag status after a damning “mystery shopper” report by an environmental charity.

Yesterday, 11:58

It used to be the most polluted primary in Islington – now St John Evangelist is the first school to ban cars at pick-up and drop-off times.

Yesterday, 10:23

Eastenders actor and Celebrity Masterchef winner John Partridge will be switching on the Archway Christmas lights.

Promoted Content

Fostering older teenagers means giving them the skills for life as an adult. Here, a supportive lodgings carer with Islington Council and young adult who has left care share their stories

Newsletter Sign Up

Islington Gazette twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

Most read

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Islington Gazette
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now