Highest European court rules Islington Council was right to discipline Christian registrar who refused to marry gay couples
Lillian Ladele Pic: Johnny Green/PA - Credit: PA Archive/Press Association Ima
The long-running saga of a Christian registrar disciplined for refusing to conduct gay civil partnerships could now be over.
European judges this week told Lillian Ladele, who resigned in 2009 after telling Islington Council she couldn’t oversee same-sex unions, that she can take her case no further.
Miss Ladele, who refused to perform gay ceremonies “as a matter of religious conscience”, wanted to take the matter to the Grand Chamber of the Court after the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) rejected her case earlier this year.
She claimed to have been all but forced out of her job and that she suffered ridicule and bullying as a result of her beliefs – an accusation upheld by an employment tribunal in 2008.
A subsequent appeal overturned that decision, and in their latest ruling judges said that disciplinary proceedings against her were justified and the council was bound by duties not to discriminate against their clients and could not support staff who refused to work with homosexual couples.
You may also want to watch:
Richard Watts, Islington Council’s executive councillor for finance and performance, said: “The council welcomes this decision. No public servant has the right to discriminate against people while performing their duties, and the council’s position on this matter was previously upheld by the British courts.”
Equality
Most Read
- 1 Reaction from winners of Islington by-elections
- 2 Islington reports lowest coronavirus infection rate in London
- 3 'Massive stabbing' in Old Street: Man attacked outside Moorfields Hospital
- 4 London elections 2021: Latest results as they come in live
- 5 Prime minister to give green light for May 17 Covid-19 lockdown easing
- 6 900-year-old Farringdon market can continue despite opposition
- 7 Whittington NHS bosses announce maternity transformation plans
- 8 Sharks and rooftop pavilions: Time for planning laws 'middle way'
- 9 What's opening in Islington when Covid lockdown rules ease on May 17?
- 10 Arsenal midfielder Jill Roord completes move to Bundesliga side VfL Wolfsburg
Keith Porteous Wood, executive director of the National Secular Society, said: “Fortunately, Europe’s highest court has now wisely followed numerous lower courts and rejected the applicant’s attempts for religious conscience to trump equality law.
“The UK has the world’s most comprehensive equality laws which already include strong protection for religious believers and they would have been fatally compromised, particularly for LGBT [lesbian, gay, bisexual, transexual] people, had the Grand Chamber overturned any of these judgments.
“We hope that this will now draw a line under the attempts by a small coterie of Christian activists to obtain special privileges for themselves which would invariably come at the expense of other people’s rights.
“The principle of equality for all, including for religious believers, is now established and they should stop wasting the time of the courts with these vexatious cases.”
